Immigrants' Role in $313 Billion Tax Revenue at Risk

Dive Right Into

Key Takeaways

• Immigrants contribute $96.7 billion annually in taxes, heavily funding vital U.S. programs like Social Security and Medicare.
• IRS policy linking tax data to ICE creates mistrust, risking $313 billion in lost revenues if compliance drops.
• Simplifying tax processes and decoupling IRS-ICE links can restore trust and aid immigrant tax participation.

The United States, over the years, has relied on a steady flow of tax revenues to fund essential services for its population. A key player in maintaining these revenues is the contribution of immigrants 🗽, both documented and undocumented. Immigrants have consistently contributed billions of dollars annually to financial systems at all levels of government. However, current policies and administrative actions are generating significant fear among immigrant communities. If immigrants decide to halt tax filings due to fear of deportation or mistrust toward governing institutions, the U.S. economy could face a devastating $313 billion loss in tax revenues over time. This article explores the dynamics that might lead to such a loss, the economic and social impacts, and actionable steps to avert this situation.

Why Tax Filings Among Immigrants Are at Risk

Recent actions by government agencies have fueled uncertainty in immigrant communities, leading to fears that their tax information could be used against them. One notable instance occurred in April 2025, when Melanie Krause, acting commissioner of the IRS, resigned following the announcement of a controversial policy. This policy permits the sharing of tax data between the IRS and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), allowing ICE to use this information to identify and possibly deport undocumented immigrants.

While this move was justified by some as a tool to strengthen law enforcement, immigrant advocates argue that it risks pushing these communities away from participating in the tax system. A report by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), released in February 2025, underlines this concern. It noted that when the link between tax filings and deportation becomes evident, trust decreases significantly, leading to a sharp drop in compliance with tax rules. For every 10% fall in tax compliance within immigrant populations, the U.S. federal government stands to lose $8.6 billion annually, while state and local governments may lose $900 million annually.

Immigrants’ Substantial Contributions

The numbers behind immigrants’ tax contributions reveal just how deeply they are woven into the United States’ financial tapestry. In 2022 alone, undocumented immigrants paid about $96.7 billion in total taxes. Of this, $59.4 billion went to the federal government, and $37.3 billion was allocated to state and local governments. These contributions fund key programs such as Social Security, Medicare, public education, and essential infrastructure. It is worth noting that a significant part of these contributions, particularly through Social Security, comes from immigrants who do not qualify to access these benefits. This means they are effectively subsidizing services that benefit the broader population.

If immigrants refrained from filing taxes, the ripple effects would be massive. For every one million undocumented immigrants who disengage from tax systems, ITEP estimates nearly $8.9 billion in yearly revenue losses for the United States. Public services would face greater budget strain, with reduced funding affecting programs that millions of residents depend on daily.

The broader implications of decreased tax compliance among immigrants stretch far beyond financial losses. Socially, tax filing has long been regarded by many immigrants as a way to participate in civic life and contribute to society, even if they do not have access to all the privileges citizens enjoy. Filing taxes builds trust, strengthens community ties, and can sometimes serve as evidence of good moral character in immigration processes.

However, policies that tie tax filings to immigration enforcement erode this sense of trust. Many immigrants now view participating in the tax system as an act with significant personal risk. In Colorado, documented stories reveal that families hesitate to insert their personal details into public systems, fearing their compliance might later lead to deportation proceedings.

This fear-driven avoidance has a snowballing effect. A growing number of immigrant families withdrawing from the tax system can deepen their social exclusion, leaving them unable to claim refunds, credits, or benefits for which they may be eligible. Such divisions worsen societal rifts and make integration into the broader community even harder for immigrants.

Federal Policies Adding Complexity

In addition to fears of deportation, tax policy changes—such as those affecting the Child Tax Credit (CTC) and the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC)—have left immigrant families facing challenges. For instance, the expiration of measures preventing misuse of these credits, implemented under the 2017 tax reforms by President Trump, has reintroduced complications.

The CTC and EITC programs are notoriously complex, requiring accurate documentation for eligibility, which may add to an immigrant’s stress. Already, language barriers and minimal knowledge of taxes make filing processes challenging. If families misunderstand how these programs affect them, they may believe it is safer to avoid the tax system altogether.

Moreover, logistical challenges reinforce avoidance of tax filings. Immigrant taxpayers often need an ITIN—Individual Taxpayer Identification Number—to complete their returns. However, obtaining an ITIN can take weeks, requiring the submission of sensitive documents like passports. This delays resolution and discourages participation—especially for immigrant families coping with time and financial constraints.

Why Simplicity in Policy Matters

The United States must prioritize simplicity and fairness in its tax policies to encourage immigrant participation. Complicated systems and miscommunication sow distrust and make compliance seem unattainable. If participation diminishes, the government forfeits the broader civic and economic benefits that arise from an engaged and contributing immigrant community.

Policy Recommendations to Reverse the Trend

Addressing the impending $313 billion tax gap requires thoughtful and immediate solutions at multiple levels. Proposed measures include:

Streamlining Tax-Filing Processes
Simplified instructions, multilingual resources, and digital filing tools could make it easier for immigrants to file their taxes correctly and on time. Making the ITIN application process more efficient would help reduce administrative frustrations currently discouraging tax compliance.
Establishing Tax Credits for All Workers
Extending access to programs like the CTC and EITC regardless of immigration status could incentivize more filing participation. When families see direct benefits tied to paying taxes, their willingness to comply increases.
Lore Rebuilding Trust with Clear Education Campaigns
Public outreach initiatives that counter fears of tax filing can encourage participation. Trusted immigrant organizations and community workers can serve as bridges to explain tax benefits and reassure families of confidentiality.
Decoupling Immigration Enforcement from Tax-Filing Activities
One of the most effective steps to rebuild immigrant trust might involve enforcing strict barriers to prevent collaboration between tax agencies like the IRS and immigration enforcement bodies. This will reassure immigrant families that complying with taxes will not lead to deportation.

Final Thoughts: The High Stakes of $313 Billion

Immigrants bring undeniable economic benefits to the United States—not just as contributors to industries and culture but as taxpayers. Their role keeps public services afloat and helps protect future generations. Policies creating fear and administrative inefficiencies risk alienating an entire workforce responsible for $313 billion in vital revenue.

In addressing this challenge, solutions must address trust, fairness, and inclusivity. Encouraging tax compliance through simplified processes ensures both fairness for immigrant households and broader economic stability. A proactive approach could reaffirm the U.S.’s standing as a country that values contributions from all who live and work within its communities.

For more information about how the U.S. tax system works for immigrants, visit the IRS Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) page.

Embracing inclusive tax solutions could strengthen not just budgets but also the very fabric of American society, helping immigrants fulfill their potential while ensuring collective progress.

Learn Today

Immigrant Tax Contribution → Taxes paid by immigrants to federal, state, and local governments, funding programs like Medicare and Social Security.
Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) → A number issued by the IRS to individuals ineligible for a Social Security Number for tax purposes.
Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP) → A non-profit organization analyzing taxation’s impact on economic policies and public revenues.
Child Tax Credit (CTC) → A federal tax credit benefiting eligible families with children, aimed at reducing their tax liability.
Deportation Proceedings → Legal processes where non-citizens may be removed from the U.S. for violating immigration laws.

This Article in a Nutshell

Immigrants contribute billions annually, yet ICE’s access to IRS data generates fear, risking $313 billion in lost U.S. tax revenues. Addressing this requires streamlined processes, inclusive policies, and trust-building measures. Decoupling tax filings from immigration enforcement ensures sustained immigrant engagement and economic stability for critical public services nationwide. Inclusive policies are essential.
— By VisaVerge.com

• IRS Data Sharing with ICE Could Put Billions in Tax Revenue at Risk
• Flywire Cuts 125 Jobs as Student Visa Restrictions Hit Revenue
• Trump Tax Cuts Could Cost Federal Revenue Up to $11 Trillion
• Canada’s International Student Visa Cap Threatens University Revenue
• Canadian Visa Restrictions Lead to Drop in Mexican Tourists and Tourism Revenue