Toor Vineyards Fined $118K, Banned from Hiring Foreign Workers

Dive Right Into

Key Takeaways

Toor Vineyards was permanently banned from hiring temporary foreign workers and fined $118,000 for severe violations under the TFWP.
Violations included worker abuse, contract discrepancies, and repeated infractions, reflecting broader concerns about protecting migrant workers in Canada.
Rare permanent bans highlight systemic issues; advocates call for stronger preventative measures to safeguard vulnerable temporary foreign workers.

A British Columbia winery, Toor Vineyards—also known as Desert Hills Estate Winery in Oliver, B.C.—has been permanently banned from hiring temporary foreign workers and fined $118,000 by the federal government. This action, announced on January 6, 2025, comes as a result of the winery’s repeated violations of the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP). These violations raise serious concerns about the treatment of migrant workers in Canada and the challenges involved in ensuring fair workplace practices.

Examination of Violations

Toor Vineyards Fined $118K, Banned from Hiring Foreign Workers

Toor Vineyards failed to meet several key regulations under the TFWP. The federal authorities found that the winery did not provide necessary documents to inspectors and failed to ensure a workplace free of abuse, including physical, sexual, psychological, or financial forms. More concerning was the inconsistency between the pay and conditions promised in workers’ contracts and those actually provided.

The violations, considered one of the most severe cases under the program, earned the winery a permanent ban from using the TFWP. Such a penalty is extraordinarily rare and is typically applied only in cases of significant non-compliance. This isn’t the first time Toor Vineyards or its associated operator, Desert Hills Estate Winery, has faced scrutiny for such actions. In 2023, the company was fined $16,000 for similar TFWP infractions. Even earlier, in 2022, Toor Vineyards was fined $90,000 for its involvement in a province-wide immigration fraud scheme. This repeated disregard for labor laws appears to demonstrate an ongoing lack of concern for the well-being and rights of temporary foreign workers.

The Government’s Firm Response

The $118,000 fine is one of the largest penalties imposed under the TFWP in recent years and is part of the government’s broader efforts to crack down on the exploitation of migrant workers. Employers who violate the program’s regulations can face hefty fines, temporary suspensions, or permanent bans, depending on the severity and recurrence of their actions.

According to Navid Bayat, staff lawyer at the Migrant Workers Centre, the fine is notably large. He hopes that such a penalty will send a clear message to other employers about the serious consequences of exploiting their workers. Temporary foreign workers often face tremendous risks when coming to Canada, including language barriers, lack of legal support, and fear of losing their employment or facing deportation. Bayat emphasized that permanent bans like the one imposed on Toor Vineyards are rare and typically reflect systemic abuse of labor rights.

This action by the federal government reflects an increasing willingness to enforce labor standards. However, advocates continue to call for stronger preventative measures to protect vulnerable workers, arguing that fines, while necessary, only address the problem after the harm has already occurred.

Allegations Against Randhir Toor

The controversy surrounding Toor Vineyards doesn’t end with these violations. Allegations of sexual assault by the winery’s former owner, Randhir (Randy) Toor, have added another layer of concern. Early in 2024, a migrant worker from Mexico came forward accusing Toor of sexual assault. No criminal charges have been filed yet, but the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) have urged others who may have experienced similar issues to come forward.

This is not the first time Randhir Toor has made headlines. In 2022, he admitted guilt to seven counts of advising or attempting to aid misrepresentation under Canada’s Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. By the end of 2023, Toor announced via social media his retirement from active involvement with Desert Hills Estate Winery.

Such allegations and legal troubles reflect broader concerns about the accountability of employers who hire temporary foreign workers. Without strong oversight, these workers may continue to be at risk of exploitation or abuse while working far from home.

Broader Concerns Within the TFWP

The violations by Toor Vineyards bring attention to long-standing criticisms of the Temporary Foreign Worker Program itself. Critics argue that the program does not do enough to prevent abuse and exploitation. Many workers under the TFWP are in a vulnerable position due to language barriers and limited access to legal advice. They may also be hesitant to speak out against unfair treatment, fearing job loss or deportation.

Advocacy groups have been pushing for reforms to improve worker conditions. Some of their recommendations include increased inspections, better access to legal resources for workers, and stricter conditions for employers to participate in the TFWP. While the penalties against Toor Vineyards are substantial, many experts believe that punishing violations is not as effective as taking proactive measures to prevent mistreatment in the first place.

Rarity of Permanent Bans

Permanent bans under the TFWP remain extremely rare, making the penalty against Toor Vineyards especially notable. Since 2016, only one other business across Canada has faced a permanent ban for violating the program. Of the nearly 1,000 employer violations recorded in recent years, most resulted in monetary fines or temporary suspensions. This highlights how severe the infractions at Toor Vineyards were and shows how unusual it is for the government to take such a hardline approach.

This rarity also raises questions about whether businesses found guilty of exploiting workers are being punished harshly enough. Advocates argue that penalties like temporary bans or small fines might not be sufficient to deter other employers from taking advantage of temporary foreign workers.

Closing Thoughts

The case of Toor Vineyards and its $118,000 fine underscores critical issues surrounding the Temporary Foreign Worker Program and the treatment of migrant workers in Canada. This penalty, combined with the permanent ban, draws attention to the importance of holding employers accountable for their treatment of workers. For migrant workers who rely on programs like the TFWP to support their families back home, such enforcement measures are vital.

However, this case also raises broader questions about the effectiveness of Canada’s current approach to protecting temporary foreign workers. While the actions taken against Toor Vineyards send a strong message, critics argue that they highlight the need for further reforms to ensure that abuse and exploitation are prevented before they occur.

As investigations against Randhir Toor continue, the penalties imposed on Toor Vineyards will likely remain a focal point in discussions around better workplace protections. As reported by VisaVerge.com, these developments should serve as both a warning for employers and a call to improve existing systems to ensure the safety and well-being of all workers. For official details on the TFWP requirements, you can visit Canada’s government website on the Temporary Foreign Worker Program.

This moment in Canada’s labor policies could set a new precedent for how worker rights are defended, particularly in industries relying heavily on temporary foreign labor.

B.C. winery fined $118K, permanently banned from foreign worker program

The federal government has fined Toor Vineyards—operating as Desert Hills Estate Winery—$118,000 and issued a permanent ban from the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP) over multiple labor violations. This marks one of the most severe penalties ever under the TFWP.

Why it matters:
The case highlights ongoing issues with the treatment of temporary foreign workers in Canada and the government’s efforts to enforce labor standards. It also underscores the vulnerability of migrant workers and the systemic gaps in oversight and enforcement.

The big picture:
– History of non-compliance: Toor Vineyards had previously been fined $90,000 in 2022 for immigration fraud and $16,000 in 2023 for labor violations. The permanent ban follows a pattern of repeated offenses.
– Worker mistreatment: Inspectors found the winery failed to provide safe workplaces and offered work conditions inconsistent with employment contracts, including instances of abuse and insufficient safeguards.
– Rarity of penalties: Since 2016, only one other business has faced a permanent ban among nearly 1,000 violations documented under the TFWP.

What they’re saying:
– Navid Bayat, staff lawyer at the Migrant Workers Centre: Described the fine as “significant” and noted it highlights systemic labor violations. “Migrant workers are particularly vulnerable due to language barriers and fear of deportation,” he said.
– The federal government emphasized that penalties like these are critical tools to protect vulnerable workers and ensure employer accountability.

Between the lines:
Critics argue that the TFWP’s oversight mechanisms remain insufficient, allowing employers to exploit workers with limited reporting avenues. Advocates are pushing for more proactive measures, such as increased inspections and immediate protections for workers who report mistreatment.

By the numbers:
– $118,000: Fine issued to Toor Vineyards, one of the largest under the TFWP.
– 2: Instances in the past two years where the winery was penalized for violations.
– 1,000+: TFWP violations recorded since 2016; only two led to permanent bans.

Allegations against former owner:
The case is compounded by ongoing investigations into former owner Randhir Toor, accused of sexually assaulting a Mexican migrant worker. No charges have been filed, but Toor previously admitted guilt in 2022 to immigration misrepresentation charges.

State of play:
Advocates are calling for stronger protections for temporary foreign workers, including better legal access, workplace safety assurances, and penalties for abusive employers that go beyond fines. Critics say reactive measures fail to prevent systemic exploitation.

The bottom line:
The penalties against Toor Vineyards expose significant flaws in Canada’s handling of temporary foreign labor. While the rare permanent ban sends a strong message, addressing the deeper systemic issues of worker protections and employer accountability remains critical to preventing future exploitation.

Learn Today

TFWP (Temporary Foreign Worker Program): A Canadian program allowing employers to hire foreign workers for temporary jobs when no locals are available.
Non-compliance: Failure to follow or meet regulations, standards, or conditions set by a governing body or program.
Exploitation: Taking unfair advantage of someone, often through abuse of power or position, for personal or financial gain.
Labor standards: Regulations set to protect workers’ rights, including fair wages, safe environments, and freedom from abuse.
Immigration and Refugee Protection Act: Canada’s legal framework governing immigration, refugee protection, and addressing immigration-related offenses.

This Article in a Nutshell

A historic $118,000 fine and permanent ban on hiring temporary foreign workers highlight serious violations at Toor Vineyards in British Columbia. Allegations of exploitation and abuse expose systemic issues within Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program. Advocates urge stronger safeguards to prevent harm, emphasizing accountability and proactive reforms to protect vulnerable migrant workers nationwide.
— By VisaVerge.com