Impact of Reduced Canada Immigration on Economic Growth, According to RBC

Canada's economic growth heavily relies on immigration to offset an aging population and labor shortages. Immigrants boost labor supply and consumer demand, vital for mitigating economic slowdowns. Recent policy shifts aim to balance housing affordability with sustaining immigration. Experts argue for comprehensive strategies to maintain economic vitality and social well-being by ensuring a steady influx of immigrants and temporary workers.

Oliver Mercer
By Oliver Mercer - Chief Editor 7 Min Read

Key Takeaways:

  • RBC Economics stresses immigration’s crucial role in counteracting aging population impact, boosting Canada’s economic growth sustainably.
  • Temporary immigration surge witnessed in Canada post-COVID-19; crucial for addressing labor shortages, public finances amid demographic shifts.
  • Maintaining robust immigration levels vital for Canada’s economy, countering labor shortages, and sustaining social well-being long-term.

The Economic Imperative of Sustaining Canada Immigration

In a recent forecast by RBC Economics, the significant impact of immigration on Canada’s economic growth and its vital role in cushioning the effects of an aging population have been underscored. As the country stands at a critical juncture, especially with the looming challenges presented by the retiring Baby Boomer generation, the importance of temporary immigration has never been more clear.

Impact of Reduced Canada Immigration on Economic Growth, According to RBC
Impact of Reduced Canada Immigration on Economic Growth, According to RBC

How Does Immigration Fuel Canada’s Economic Growth?

Immigration infuses vitality into Canada’s economy in multiple ways. Senior Economist Nathan Janzen of RBC elucidates this phenomenon by stating, “When the population rises via immigration, it essentially floats all boats.” This phenomenon is multifaceted:

  • Boosting Labor Supply: Immigrants expand the workforce, enabling Canada to produce more goods and services.
  • Stimulating Consumer Demand: Every new resident contributes to the demand for products, further invigorating the economy.

However, the prospect of reduced immigration poses a real threat. Slower population growth implies a double-edged sword of dwindling demand and supply of workers, which could curtail the economy’s total output. Janzen predicts that a slowdown in population growth could slash Canada’s economic growth by approximately 0.5% by the end of 2025.

The Surge in Temporary Immigration

During the initial years of the COVID-19 pandemic, Canada saw a notable influx of temporary residents. The data from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) reveals a striking increase, from 522,110 temporary residents in 2019 to over 1.6 million by the end of 2023.

Yet, in light of rising housing affordability concerns, measures have been instituted to cap the number of new study permits to 606,250 this year. Further action is expected with Canada’s first temporary immigration levels plan set to be unveiled in September, aiming to cut the number of temporary residents significantly over three years.

The Vital Role of Temporary Workers and International Students

Temporary foreign workers and international students stand as pillars supporting Canada through the transition engendered by retiring Baby Boomers. Their contribution is manifold:

  • Easing Labor Shortages: With many Canadian workers reaching retirement age, these groups help fill crucial gaps in the labor market.
  • Sustaining Public Finances: They play a part in offsetting the fiscal pressures of an aging population by contributing to tax revenues while utilizing fewer social services.

RBC’s report emphasizes the critical nature of this demographic challenge, cautioning that without adequate levels of immigration, labor shortages, previously mitigated by high interest rates, are likely to re-emerge as a persistent issue.

Addressing Housing Affordability Without Stifling Immigration

While the government has posited restricting immigration as a remedy for housing affordability, experts like Janzen argue against this approach. “The shortage of housing in Canada … is decades in the making and predates the recent surge in population growth,” he remarks. The fundamental issue lies in supply-side constraints, underscoring that reducing immigration may inadvertently hamper the labor supply in construction and other sectors critical to addressing the housing shortage.

In 2022 alone, the 242,000 new housing starts were unable to keep pace with the approximately 360,000 new households resulting from population growth. This mismatch underscores the pressing need for a more proactive housing strategy, one that expands the availability of affordable housing rather than curbs population growth.

A Holistic Approach to Sustaining Economic Growth and Social Well-being

The consensus among economists, including Desjardins’ Marc Desormeaux, highlights the economic jeopardy posed by restricting temporary immigration. History and data suggest that such measures could exacerbate economic downturns, especially in Canada’s largest provinces.

To navigate these complex challenges, Canada must balance the imperative of addressing housing affordability with the need to sustain immigration levels. This calls for comprehensive policy measures that enhance the construction and availability of affordable housing while maintaining an open, inviting stance toward temporary workers and international students. Their contributions are indispensable, not just economically, but in enriching the cultural and social fabric of Canadian society.

For further details on Canada’s immigration policies and their economic implications, referencing authoritative sources such as the Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) website ensures access to the most current and accurate information.

In conclusion, sustaining healthy levels of immigration, particularly amid an aging population and labor market challenges, is not just a matter of economic expediency for Canada. It is a strategic imperative that promises to shape the nation’s economic landscape and social well-being for decades to come. Through careful planning and a forward-looking approach, Canada can navigate these demographic shifts, ensuring a prosperous, vibrant future for all residents, new and old.

This Article In A Nutshell:

Immigration is crucial for Canada’s economy, counteracting aging demographics and stimulating growth. Temporary residents, like foreign workers and students, play a vital role. Restricting immigration may worsen housing shortages. Balancing policies to boost construction and immigration is key for economic stability and social enrichment. Canada’s future prosperity hinges on sustaining immigration.
— By VisaVerge.com

Read More:

Share This Article
Oliver Mercer
Chief Editor
Follow:
As the Chief Editor at VisaVerge.com, Oliver Mercer is instrumental in steering the website's focus on immigration, visa, and travel news. His role encompasses curating and editing content, guiding a team of writers, and ensuring factual accuracy and relevance in every article. Under Oliver's leadership, VisaVerge.com has become a go-to source for clear, comprehensive, and up-to-date information, helping readers navigate the complexities of global immigration and travel with confidence and ease.
Leave a Comment
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments