Key Takeaways
• Utah lawyer Nicole Micheroni mistakenly received a DHS self-deportation email despite being a U.S. citizen by birth.
• Thousands, including other citizens and green card holders, received similar erroneous self-deport notices due to administrative mistakes.
• DHS acknowledges the email error and is reviewing procedures to prevent further mistaken deportation messages.
Nicole Micheroni, a Utah immigration lawyer, recently faced an unusual and troubling situation. She received an official-looking email from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) telling her it was time to leave the United States. This message included a direct statement: “It’s time for you to leave the United States… DHS is now exercising its discretion to terminate your parole. Unless it expires sooner, your parole will terminate 7 days from the date of this notice.” The problem? Micheroni is not only an attorney who helps others with immigration issues, but she was born in the United States 🇺🇸 and is a citizen by birth. She never held an immigration parole status.
This mistake was not unique to Micheroni. Across the country, others also received similar messages. Some were green card holders, some had visas, and even other U.S. citizens found these emails in their inboxes. The instruction to self-deport—meaning to leave the country on your own instead of being forced out—sparked fear and confusion among recipients. These errors did not just create personal worries for Micheroni and her family. They sent shockwaves through communities that rely on guidance from professionals, like a Utah immigration lawyer, to understand and deal with the ever-changing rules set by the Department of Homeland Security.
Why Did These Self-Deport Emails Happen?
To understand why someone like Micheroni was mistakenly told to self-deport, it’s important to know what was happening with immigration policy at the national level. The country’s immigration system was going through many changes due to recent decisions by the Supreme Court and new enforcement priorities.
President Biden’s administration had used special powers to allow people from certain countries—such as Cuba 🇨🇺, Haiti 🇭🇹, Nicaragua 🇳🇮, and Venezuela 🇻🇪—to enter the United States under a process called “humanitarian parole.” This process gave people who were facing danger or hardship a short-term legal way to stay in the country. The Department of Homeland Security managed these programs, which helped more than 500,000 people, while they tried to get more permanent status.
But, when the Supreme Court allowed mass removals under the Alien Enemies Act (AEA), priorities changed quickly. The government started to wind down or end some of these parole programs. As a result, many people who were allowed to stay temporarily suddenly faced the prospect of losing their legal permission to be in the United States 🇺🇸.
The DHS and its agency, Customs and Border Protection (CBP), sent out a large number of emails telling people about their change in status. These messages included instructions to self-deport, which means the person should leave on their own without being arrested and made to leave forcibly. In theory, this should only have affected those whose special status was ending.
However, something went wrong. Some of the emails included American citizens and legal residents who should never have received such notices. DHS has since admitted that some of these emails were sent by mistake.
How Did American Citizens Get These Self-Deport Orders?
A senior DHS official explained that Customs and Border Protection was managing a huge list of email contacts, many of which were not individual email accounts. Sometimes, families or law offices share email addresses when handling multiple immigration cases. In other cases, immigrants list their attorney as an official contact for urgent DHS news, so nothing important goes unnoticed.
But when emails are sent to “shared” inboxes, or if a client accidentally lists their lawyer’s email as theirs, officials end up with many addresses that do not strictly belong to the immigrant. As CBP sent out thousands of emails, a number of them went to immigration attorneys, their assistants, family members, and, as in Nicole Micheroni’s case, even to American citizens unconnected with any ongoing parole or removal action.
The notice Nicole Micheroni received was not an order meant for her. Yet, the words were clear and severe, stating she had just seven days left before her parole would expire and she must leave the country. For someone who works daily to help others avoid deportation, the irony and confusion were hard to ignore.
CBP has since said these mistakes happen, and they are working on each case as it comes up. They have to check their databases to avoid similar errors, especially for American citizens and people with legal residency who should not be told to self-deport.
How Do Self-Deport Notices Affect People?
Getting an official message from the Department of Homeland Security ordering self-deportation is deeply worrying. Even when received by mistake, these messages have quick and disturbing effects:
- Fear and Uncertainty: Recipients, legal or not, often panic. If you’re a green card holder or visa holder, the notice may make you question your own status.
- Disruption to Daily Life: Many people drop everything to call their lawyers or scramble to find documents that prove their right to be in the U.S.
- Trust in the System Drops: When citizens and legal residents receive deportation notices in error, everyone’s confidence in government accuracy is shaken. People start to worry about whether the next mistake will land them in a more serious position.
For attorneys like Micheroni, who represent clients facing real immigration struggles, an error like this is more than just an annoyance. It’s a wake-up call about the need for extra checks and good communication. Clients count on a Utah immigration lawyer to be calm, knowledgeable, and capable of cutting through government paperwork and confusion. When lawyers themselves get these mistaken messages, it highlights how errors can happen to anyone.
What Is Humanitarian Parole—and Why Was It Ended?
President Biden’s parole programs were designed as temporary solutions. People from countries facing political chaos, violence, or disaster were given the chance to enter the United States legally for a period. This move provided safety, allowed families to reunite, and gave hope to people who would otherwise be forced to return to dangerous situations.
However, parole does not equal permanent status. It’s a short-term measure, and people must try to get a green card or another kind of longer-term legal protection as soon as they can. As the DHS began closing these parole programs, more than 532,000 people—many from Cuba 🇨🇺, Haiti 🇭🇹, Nicaragua 🇳🇮, and Venezuela 🇻🇪—faced losing their legal foothold.
When the programs stopped, the emails followed. That’s why so many deportation notifications were being issued all at once.
DHS and CBP’s Official Response to the Error
After the mistake was revealed, the Department of Homeland Security and Customs and Border Protection clarified the following points:
- The self-deport emails were meant only for people whose humanitarian parole was ending.
- All emails sent to American citizens or people with legal residency were mistakes, not intentional actions.
- CBP is now double-checking email lists and ways notices are sent to avoid more errors.
- Every mistaken instance is reviewed and resolved case by case, aiming to stop unnecessary panic.
This response is important, but going forward, every recipient—whether immigrant, visa-holder, lawyer, or citizen—should know how to check their status and understand what to do if they receive an unexpected message about self-deportation.
Historical Background on Self-Deport Orders
Ordering a person to self-deport isn’t a new part of the U.S. immigration system. In many cases, this approach is seen as a less harsh way to handle people who are out of status than forced removal. The process is direct: the person is told to plan their own departure and provide proof they left the United States.
Most people who receive these notices are undocumented or have stayed beyond their visa or humanitarian parole term. However, the rise in administrative mistakes—especially those involving U.S. citizens—raises concerns about checks and balances in how government agencies manage personal information.
Mistaken orders to self-deport are a reminder that even advanced government systems can make basic errors, especially when handling thousands of rapid changes.
Implications for Immigrants, Lawyers, and the General Public
The impact of this incident goes beyond the one Utah immigration lawyer. There are lessons for several groups:
For Immigrants:
The confusion shows how important it is to keep immigration records updated and to make sure your own contact details are current. Always provide the right email and double-check with your lawyer before making changes.
For Immigration Lawyers:
If you represent clients, make sure their contact information with USCIS or DHS is correct and not mixed with your law office or personal contacts. Clear records help avoid mistakes like the one faced by Micheroni.
For the General Public:
Even American citizens not involved in any immigration case can get caught up in technical glitches or errors. Stay calm, double-check your citizenship status, and reach out to reliable resources or a trusted attorney if you get any official message connected to immigration.
For the Department of Homeland Security:
This mistake was widely reported, which shines a spotlight on the need for careful data management. Regular audits of notification systems can help lower the risk of confusion and fear in the future.
How Should You Respond If You Get a Self-Deport Order by Mistake?
If you get a message from the Department of Homeland Security telling you to self-deport by mistake, don’t panic. Here are simple steps you should follow:
- Check the Details: Read the email or letter carefully. Does it have your correct name, date of birth, and status?
- Contact USCIS or DHS Quickly: Use official phone numbers and online portals—not numbers in suspicious emails—to confirm your status.
- Reach Out to an Attorney: If you have an immigration lawyer, send them a copy of the message right away. They know how to communicate with DHS on your behalf.
- Gather Your Documents: Keep your birth certificate, proof of citizenship, or green card close by, so you can respond to questions easily.
- Report the Error: Go to the official DHS website to report any mistaken communication and get guidance about what to do next.
As reported by VisaVerge.com, the current pattern of errors linked to mass notification efforts shows why clear records and direct communication between the government and those it serves are more important than ever.
Conclusion: The Need for Accuracy and Care in Immigration Enforcement
Nicole Micheroni’s story started as a shocking error—a citizen and Utah immigration lawyer told by DHS to leave her own country. But it revealed a larger issue. When immigration rules change quickly, and systems send messages in bulk, even experienced professionals can get caught up in mistakes.
For the hundreds of thousands of immigrants losing humanitarian parole, getting the correct information determines whether they stay or leave. For U.S. citizens, green card holders, and visa holders, a mistaken message can mean hours or days of needless fear.
Government agencies like the Department of Homeland Security must take care to reach only those truly affected by status changes. Each email or letter should be double-checked before sending. For everyone else, know your rights, keep your documents safe, and don’t hesitate to ask a professional, such as a Utah immigration lawyer, if you have doubts about your immigration status or any official messages.
Mistakes like these remind all of us why trust, accuracy, and clear records matter so much in the immigration process. To learn more about your rights or how to report errors, check the latest updates on the Department of Homeland Security’s website. That way, if you or someone you know receives a notice to self-deport by mistake, you’ll know what to do and how to stay protected.
Learn Today
Humanitarian Parole → A temporary legal permission allowing people to enter or stay in the U.S. for urgent or humanitarian reasons.
Self-Deportation → The process where an immigrant is instructed to leave the country voluntarily, rather than being formally removed by authorities.
Green Card Holder → A person who has lawful permanent resident status in the United States with authorization to live and work.
Department of Homeland Security (DHS) → U.S. federal agency overseeing immigration, border security, and protection against threats.
Customs and Border Protection (CBP) → Federal agency within DHS responsible for regulating and facilitating international trade, immigration, and enforcing border laws.
This Article in a Nutshell
A Utah immigration lawyer, Nicole Micheroni, received an alarming DHS email instructing her to leave the U.S. within seven days. Though a citizen, she was mistakenly included in a mass notification error affecting citizens, green card holders, and others. DHS is investigating the issue and updating its communication practices.
— By VisaVerge.com
Read more:
• CHNV travel authorization validity details released by Homeland Security
• Youngkin says Virginia Homeland Security Task Force arrested 500 illegal immigrants
• Connecticut doctor told by Homeland Security to leave the US
• Homeland Security’s Role in Washtenaw County Immigration Inquiry
• University of Oregon students face visa revocations by Homeland Security
