Key Takeaways
• A January 2025 executive order introduced enhanced vetting for green card holders and foreign students, complicating re-entry and increasing travel risks.
• Non-citizens aged 14+ must now register with the government within 30 days; failure leads to civil or criminal consequences.
• Foreign students face stricter compliance enforcement; political activism risks deportation under new executive orders, impacting free speech protections.
Green card holders (lawful permanent residents) and foreign students in the United States enjoy certain protections under immigration and constitutional law. However, recent changes to U.S. immigration policies as of March 2025 have presented new challenges, impacting their rights and everyday realities. From enhanced vetting procedures to restrictions linked to political activities, these adjustments have practical consequences that demand attention from affected individuals.
Rights and Protections for Green Card Holders
Green card holders in the U.S. have historically benefited from a stable set of legal protections. They can live and work permanently in the country and largely share in constitutional rights like freedom of speech and religion. However, a series of executive orders rolled out in early 2025 has made some of these protections more precarious.
Constitutional Rights Amid New Challenges
While green card holders are not U.S. citizens, they enjoy certain constitutional safeguards. Freedom of speech and religion are fundamental rights extended to permanent residents. However, the executive order titled “Protecting the United States from Foreign Terrorists and Other National Security and Public Safety Threats,” issued on January 20, 2025, includes measures that complicate the balance between these rights and national security. There is growing concern in legal circles that these policies may result in selective enforcement, raising questions about how robust constitutional protections for LPRs remain under these shifting rules.
Employment and Travel Restrictions Heightened
LPRs traditionally enjoy freedom to seek employment and reside in any U.S. state while being able to travel internationally without extensive disruptions. But the same January 20, 2025 executive order introduced new requirements involving enhanced vetting for individuals seeking to enter the U.S.—a rule that also applies to green card holders re-entering the country. As a result, individuals traveling internationally are at risk of encountering prolonged assessments at U.S. ports of entry. Extended absences can also endanger their permanent residency altogether, creating additional anxiety for those who need to travel for familial or professional reasons.
Expanded Deportation Grounds Raise Concerns
The executive order also widened the pathway for deportation of green card holders. In particular, LPRs could now face deportation for any action considered to “undermine the fundamental constitutional rights of the American people.” This vague phrasing has led to fears of its misuse. Deportation has always been a risk for green card holders who commit certain crimes, but these new provisions seem to expand that risk to include individuals targeted for their interactions or expression, potentially creating a chilling effect on free speech among LPRs.
Protections and Pressures on Foreign Students
Foreign students studying in the United States—many holding F-1 or J-1 visas—represent another group facing heightened complexities as immigration policies evolve. Historically, foreign students have been welcomed due to their contributions to the education system and broader cultural exchange. However, new orders have introduced limitations that add complexity to their stay.
Free Speech Under Threat?
Technically, foreign students enjoy First Amendment protections, similar to those of other residents in the United States. Still, an executive order issued on January 29, 2025, targeted international students engaging in pro-Palestinian rallies, threatening them with deportation. While such measures have yet to be broadly enforced, they question the limits of free speech for non-citizen students, instilling fear among those participating in campus protests or political events.
No Change in Employment Rules, but Tighter Oversight
Foreign students continue to face stringent rules about employment. For instance, most F-1 students are still limited to working up to 20 hours a week on campus during academic terms. Off-campus employment nearly always requires authorization through programs such as Curricular Practical Training (CPT) or Optional Practical Training (OPT). Current restrictions remain unchanged, but compliance enforcement appears stricter, especially with increased attention on verifying students’ adherence to visa terms.
Complications with Travel and Re-entry
The January 2025 executive order mandating enhanced vetting for all visa holders directly affects foreign students. Travel—particularly for students from countries targeted by prior travel bans—has become fraught with delays and concerns about whether individuals will successfully regain entry after leaving the country. Re-entry complications appear to have increased, especially without clear guidance or a predictable process.
New Policy Developments Affecting Both Groups
Several recent changes have far-reaching consequences for both green card holders and foreign students:
Enhanced Vetting
The January 20, 2025 policy on enhanced vetting obligations dramatically alters how immigrants and visitors are assessed by immigration authorities. The review process now incorporates evaluations of applicants’ expressed attitudes towards American values and U.S. citizens, which many advocacy groups argue is subjective and problematic.
Alien Registration Has Returned
Non-citizens aged 14 or older must now register with the government within 30 days of arrival or turning 14—a requirement reinstated by another executive order issued in January 2025. Lapses in compliance could result in civil or criminal consequences. Green card holders, students, and other non-citizen groups are called to prioritize timely registration.
Debate Over Birthright Citizenship
The same January 20 executive order attempts to revoke birthright citizenship for children born to non-citizen parents, with enforcement set to begin in February 2025. However, this significant shift faces immediate and fierce litigation, leaving a legal stalemate in its wake as courts deliberate its constitutionality.
Heightened Deportation Efforts
The January 2025 order on “Protecting the American People Against Invasion” aims to escalate deportations by using expedited removal mechanisms and involving new Homeland Security task forces. These steps amplify risks for individuals who inadvertently fall out of lawful status.
Implications for Green Card Holders and Foreign Students
These sweeping measures carry practical implications that both green card holders and students need to consider carefully.
Exercising Caution with Travel
Given enhanced vetting and the possibility of prolonged screenings, both green card holders and foreign students are advised to limit non-essential travel outside the U.S. If travel is unavoidable, they should aim to return to the country well in advance of critical events such as the start of academic terms or new job roles.
Keeping Documents Close and Status in Order
All non-citizens—whether permanent residents, foreign students, or visitors—should ensure they comply with the new alien registration requirements and regularly verify the validity of their immigration documents. Carrying proper identification to prove lawful presence has become increasingly important under stricter enforcement practices.
Political Participation Risks
Foreign students, in particular, must weigh the potential legal risks of political activism against their visa status. Given the ambiguity introduced by newer executive orders, students should exercise informed caution when participating in demonstrations or political rallies.
The Role of Legal Challenges
Many of these policies are now entangled in court battles, presenting opportunities for their partial or full rescission. Particularly, the birthright citizenship policy faces fierce opposition, with lawsuits initiated by multiple state governments and civil liberties groups. A temporary restraining order (TRO) issued by a federal court in Washington on January 23, 2025, has already put the implementation of this policy on hold.
Similarly, legal efforts are underway to challenge restrictions on foreign students’ First Amendment rights. Civil liberties organizations are gearing up to litigate potential constitutional violations arising from the threat of deporting students based on political speech or assembly.
Final Thoughts on Compliance and Adaptation
Both green card holders and foreign students currently confront a fluid and challenging environment. While traditional protections remain in place for many issues, recent executive orders have expanded risks and responsibilities. Staying informed about the latest developments is critical. Compliance with all legal requirements, from maintaining lawful status to timely registration under new rules, is essential for avoiding unwanted penalties or deportation.
For those navigating the implications of these adjustments, seeking legal assistance early and preparing for contingencies will provide essential peace of mind. Individuals seeking official resources to better understand their situations can visit U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for detailed guidance. As VisaVerge.com highlights, informed decision-making and proactive planning are now more important than ever for green card holders and foreign students alike.
Learn Today
Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR) → An individual who holds a green card, allowing them to live and work permanently in the U.S.
Enhanced Vetting → A rigorous immigration screening process evaluating applicants’ behavior and attitudes towards U.S. values and citizens.
Curricular Practical Training (CPT) → A program allowing F-1 visa students to work off-campus when employment is part of academic coursework.
Birthright Citizenship → The legal right for individuals born on U.S. soil to automatically obtain U.S. citizenship, regardless of parents’ nationality.
Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) → A short-term legal ruling that halts enforcement of new policies until further judicial review is conducted.
This Article in a Nutshell
Navigating New Immigration Policies
2025’s U.S. immigration changes challenge green card holders and foreign students. Enhanced vetting complicates travel, stricter oversight heightens anxiety, and limits on political expression spark legal debates. Staying informed, maintaining compliance, and seeking timely legal advice are crucial. Adapting is key as traditional protections clash with evolving policies in an uncertain landscape.
— By VisaVerge.com
Read more:
• ICE Arrests Green Card Holders as Rubio Talks Deportation Plans
• ICE Arrests Green Card Holder Mahmoud Khalil Over Columbia Protests
• Immigration Group Challenges Sudden Change to USCIS Green Card Forms
• More Jobs Added to Green List for Faster Residency Applications
• Greenland PM: We Seek Our Own Path, Not Tied to Denmark or the US
