Texas Sues Biden Over Missing Citizenship Data for Voters

Dive Right Into

Key Takeaways

Texas Attorney General sues Biden administration over lack of data for verifying citizenship of 450,000 registered voters.
The lawsuit criticizes DHS and USCIS for insufficiently supporting citizenship verification via the SAVE program.
It highlights ongoing conflicts over election security and voter ID laws amid broader Republican concerns about noncitizen voting.

In a pivotal legal development, Texas 🇺🇸 Attorney General Ken Paxton has launched a lawsuit against the Biden administration, accusing it of not providing crucial data to verify the citizenship status of roughly 450,000 registered voters in Texas 🇺🇸. This lawsuit, set in the Western District of Texas 🇺🇸, points fingers at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The claim accuses these federal bodies of not following federal law requiring them to help states check if voters are eligible.

The main focus of this lawsuit is the process of checking the citizenship of voters. These voters did not use a Texas-issued driver’s license or ID when they registered. Paxton argues that the citizenship status of these individuals remains unchecked because federal agencies are not cooperating. The lawsuit claims that this lack of verification might harm election integrity, even though noncitizen voting is both illegal and very rare.

Texas Sues Biden Over Missing Citizenship Data for Voters

This legal move aligns with broader actions by Republican leaders who want to tackle worries about noncitizen voting. They argue this issue puts elections at risk, though these claims often face criticism for being exaggerated without strong evidence.

The lawsuit raises significant concerns about the role of federal agencies in election security. It specifically calls out DHS and USCIS for not providing enough support via the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) program. The SAVE program’s purpose is to help states verify a person’s citizenship or immigration status. Paxton claims that the program has limitations because it requires a special DHS-issued immigration number that state officials cannot easily access. Moreover, USCIS charges a fee for every verification request through SAVE, and this fee is expected to increase notably in the next three years.

USCIS Director Ur M. Jaddou argues that the SAVE program is the most secure option for citizenship verification. However, she admits there’s currently no other process available to assist states more effectively. This admission has only added to Texas 🇺🇸 officials’ frustration as they seek better tools for checking voter rolls.

The timing of this lawsuit is crucial, occurring just two weeks before an election, during early voting in Texas 🇺🇸. It sheds light on the continual arguments between state and federal governments over election security and mirrors larger national debates on voter ID laws and the overall safety of elections.

Politically, Republicans, including figures like former President Donald Trump, have often voiced concerns about noncitizen voting despite lacking substantial evidence. These statements are used to question election outcomes and advocate for stricter voter ID laws. On the flip side, Democrats argue these measures suppress votes, preventing eligible voters from casting their ballots, primarily affecting minority groups.

In August 2024, Texas 🇺🇸 Governor Greg Abbott claimed the removal of over one million ineligible voters from the state’s rolls, including 6,500 noncitizens. However, reports from outlets like the Texas Tribune and ProPublica question these numbers as being inflated or misleading.

The legal context adds another layer of complexity. Federal law prevents noncitizens from voting but also stops states from demanding proof of citizenship for federal elections. This odd legal situation complicates Texas’s 🇺🇸 attempts to make sure only rightful citizens vote.

The lawsuit mentions the delayed progress of the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act (“SAVE Act”), a piece of legislation that would give states more power to verify voter eligibility. The lack of movement on this act shows continued legislative challenges concerning election security.

The potential consequences and wider effects of this lawsuit are still unknown, but it fits into a bigger story. More states are seeking control over their election processes amid a perceived lack of federal action. States like Florida 🇺🇸 have filed similar lawsuits, indicating a trend among Republican-led states challenging the federal rules on voter checks.

Despite these legal actions, experts emphasize that noncitizen voting is incredibly rare and unlikely to affect election results meaningfully. Nevertheless, these lawsuits contribute to the heated political climate surrounding U.S. elections.

In wrapping up, Texas 🇺🇸’s legal challenge against the Biden administration signifies an important legal encounter over how voters are verified. It highlights ongoing friction between state and federal bodies over election safeguards and echoes larger national conversations about voter ID laws and election honesty. As this case progresses in court, it will likely influence future discussions on finding the right balance between ensuring election security and protecting the voting rights of all eligible citizens.

For further information on immigration processes and regulations, readers can visit the USCIS official website. Also, further insights into this development can be found on VisaVerge.com, providing detailed analysis of how these legal issues could affect future election processes.

Learn Today

Attorney General: A chief legal officer of a state, responsible for representing the state in legal matters.
Department of Homeland Security (DHS): A U.S. federal agency responsible for public security, including immigration and customs enforcement.
United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS): A federal agency that manages lawful immigration and processes citizenship and visa applications in the U.S.
Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) program: An online program helping agencies verify immigration and citizenship status of benefit applicants.
Noncitizen voting: The act of individuals who are not citizens participating in voting, which is illegal in federal elections.

This Article in a Nutshell

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sues the Biden administration, accusing it of withholding data vital for verifying the citizenship status of 450,000 voters. This lawsuit highlights tensions between state and federal roles in election security. Amid debates, it questions the integrity of voter ID laws and their impact on democracy.
— By VisaVerge.com