Senator Addresses Long Green Card Wait for Indians as Against American Values

Dive Right Into

Key Takeaways:

Senator Lee highlights Green Card wait: Germans wait a year, Indians over a decade; a misalignment with US values.
Indian backlog due to country cap policy leads to unbearable delays – a potential 195-year wait by 2030.
Unfair Green Card system hampers US talent attraction, echoes public outcry for “RemoveCountryCap” reforms.

What Are the Current Green Card Wait Times for Indians Compared to Other Nationalities?

In a recent statement captured in a 45-second video, Utah Senator Mike Lee highlighted the stark contrast in Green Card wait times between Indian and German applicants. According to the senator, while Germans can expect their Green Card processing to take approximately 12 months, Indians are looking at a decade-long wait, if not longer. This discrepancy, Senator Mike Lee notes, is “anti-ethical to American values,” suggesting a fundamental mismatch with the principles of equality and opportunity the United States stands for.

Senator Addresses Long Green Card Wait for Indians as Against American Values

The data supports Senator Lee’s concern, with reports indicating that more than a million Indians are currently stuck in a winding queue for U.S. green cards. Many of these individuals are skilled professionals who find themselves waiting for over ten years. As per the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), this backlog is particularly severe in the EB-1, EB-2, and EB-3 visa categories, essential for those with advanced degrees or exceptional abilities in various fields.

Why Is There a Significant Backlog for Indians Seeking Green Cards?

The primary reason behind the protracted delays faced by Indian Green Card applicants is the country cap policy. This policy places a limit on the number of Green Cards issued to nationals from each country annually. Consequently, countries with a high number of applicants, like India, end up with lengthy backlogs. The EB-2 category, which includes professionals with advanced degrees, accounts for a substantial portion of this backlog. According to recent USCIS data, an estimated 838,784 Indians are awaiting their turn in this particular category.

Adding to the complexity, projections from the Congressional Research Service (CRS) suggest that the backlog for Indians in these categories could escalate to 2,195,795 by fiscal year 2030. Such figures translate to an unthinkable wait of approximately 195 years, making the aspirations for a better life in the U.S. nearly unattainable within a single lifetime.

How Is the Green Card Wait Affecting American Values and Competitiveness?

Senator Mike Lee has pointed out that such an inequitable system not only contradicts American values but also hinders the United States’ ability to attract and retain global talent. His views resonate with many who believe that America should be a beacon of opportunity where individuals are judged on their merit and capabilities rather than their country of origin.

You can learn more about the different pathways to obtaining a Green Card here.

This discriminative delay poses not just a moral question but also a strategic drawback. The U.S. risks losing out on exceptional talents who, discouraged by the prolonged wait times, may opt to take their skills to more welcoming countries.

What Is the Public Saying About This Issue?

The frustration among those affected is palpable on social platforms like X (formerly Twitter), where numerous users express their dismay. A pointed critique noted by one user emphasizes the illogical nature of the current system: “Someone who got approved for something in 2023 shouldn’t be getting it before someone who got approved for the same thing in 2012.” This sentiment is echoed widely as many call for reforms to “RemoveCountryCap” to ensure a fairer, more balanced approach to handling Green Card applications.

Additionally, another user highlighted a common misconception about the actual wait time, clarifying that it extends beyond just a decade to what might realistically be over 130 years, given the current rates of Green Card issuance. These critiques underscore a growing public consensus that the Green Card processing system is in dire need of reform to better align with the nation’s values and needs.

Conclusion: What Needs to Change?

The current Green Card waiting situation for Indians starkly contrasts with American ideals of fairness and equal opportunity. Addressing this issue requires urgent legislative attention to amend the policies contributing to these unequal waiting times. By removing or adjusting the country cap system, the U.S. can make significant strides towards restoring its image as a land of opportunity and live up to the values that Senator Mike Lee, and many others, uphold as quintessentially American. Such changes would not only rectify ethical concerns but also reinforce the country’s competitive edge by attracting diverse and talented individuals ready to contribute to its growth and innovation sectors.

Learn Today:

Green Card: A Green Card, officially known as a Permanent Resident Card, is a document issued by the U.S. government to immigrants that grants them permanent residency in the United States. It allows holders to live and work in the U.S. permanently, providing a pathway to citizenship.
Country Cap: The country cap policy refers to the limit imposed on the number of Green Cards that can be issued to individuals from a particular country in a given fiscal year. This policy leads to discrepancies in wait times for Green Card processing based on the volume of applicants from different countries.
Backlog: In the context of immigration, a backlog refers to the accumulation of applications or cases that have not yet been processed or addressed within the expected or standard time frame. Backlogs can result from various factors, such as high demand, limited resources, or administrative constraints.
EB-1, EB-2, EB-3 Visa Categories: These are different preference categories within the employment-based immigration system in the United States.
- EB-1: Priority Workers category for individuals with extraordinary abilities, outstanding professors and researchers, and multinational managers or executives.
- EB-2: Advanced Degree Professionals category for individuals with advanced degrees or exceptional abilities.
- EB-3: Skilled Workers, Professionals, and Other Workers category for individuals with at least two years of job experience or training.
RemoveCountryCap: #RemoveCountryCap is a reform advocacy movement aimed at eliminating or modifying the country cap policy that leads to unequal Green Card wait times based on an individual’s country of origin. The movement seeks to promote fairness and equity in the immigration system by ensuring that applicants are processed based on merit rather than nationality.

This Article In A Nutshell:

Utah Senator Mike Lee spotlighted the disparity in Green Card wait times, revealing Indians face over a decade’s delay, unlike German applicants with a year-long process. This imbalance challenges American values of equality. Calls for change grow louder; reforms are crucial to uphold fairness, retain talent, and preserve U.S. competitiveness.
— By VisaVerge.com

Read More: